Create your very own custom Beenie's ice cream flavor! Order to take home, or select "One Batch Wonder" to have your flavor served in-store!
7 Days Notice. Serves 20-30.
7 Days Notice. 2.5 Gallons. Serves 50-75.
Batch yields 16-18 pints. Turn your leftover frozen wedding cake into your own ice cream flavor to gift to friends and family!
Go BIG with Beenie's! Pick your favorite flavor in jumbo form!
2-3 Days Notice. Call for Same-Day Flavors. Serves 12-16.
2-3 Days Notice. Serves 20-30.
2-3 Days Notice. 2.5 Gallons. Serves 50-75.
2 DAYS NOTICE NEEDED! Example: order Thursday for Saturday! Two layers of any flavor ice creams, up to 3 fillings, you choose the decorations! If you don't see your idea, email or DM us your inspiration for a custom quote!
Serves 5-8
Serves 8-12
Serves 12-16
Serves 20-30 (11"x15" rectangle)
TWO DAYS NOTICE NEEDED! Example: order Thursday for Saturday! Two layers of any flavor ice creams, up to 3 fillings, you choose the decorations! If you don't see your idea, email or DM us your inspiration for a custom quote!
Serves 5-8
Serves 8-10
Serves 12-16
Serves 20-30 (11"x15" rectangle)
SAME DAY! Come to the store NOW, or pay in advance here! These are premade options, available in our display freezer. We will try our best to accommodate custom message requests.
Vanilla Beenie and Chocolate ice cream, crunches and fudge filling, iced with white buttercream, "Happy Birthday" on top in red, with rainbow sprinkle borders. 6" round serves 5-8.
Vanilla Beenie and Chocolate ice cream, crunches and fudge filling, iced with white buttercream, "Happy Birthday" on top in red, with rainbow sprinkle borders. 8" round serves 8-12.
Golden Oreo and Cookies N Cream Ice Cream, crunchies and fudge filling, blended Golden and Classic Oreo crumb siding and a textured buttercream top with oreo half borders. 8" round serves 8-12
Reese's Withaspoon and Chocolate PB Cookie Dough ice cream, crunches and fudge filling, peanut butter and chocolate drizzle top, Reese's Pieces around the borders. 8" round serves 8-12
Cookie Dough and Dunkaroos ice cream, crunches and fudge filling, rainbow sprinkle siding, textured buttercream top and edible cookie dough ball borders. 8" round serves 8-12
Hand-packed, ultra-high quality, one-of-a-kind flavors with amazing texture!
Our incredible banana ice cream with Nilla wafer cookies.
Yellow Cake ice cream with real cake pieces, rainbow sprinkles, and blue buttercream.
Amaretto ice cream with black cherry halves and dark chocolate chunks.
A southern classic: sweet buttery and roasted nutty flavor notes, textured with chopped pecans.
Smooth coffee ice cream cold-steeped with freshly-ground premium dark roast coffee beans from Chiapas, Mexico.
We're proud of our chocolate, it's rich and delicious!
RIch chocolate ice cream with fudge brownie bites and fudge ripple.
Chocolate ice cream with chocolate chip cookie dough bites and peanut butter swirled throughout
Sweet cinnamon cereal ice cream with gooey/crunchy clusters of Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal
Classic coffee ice cream with Oreos mixed in
Cookie butter ice cream mixed with chocolate chip cookie dough bites and Callebaut dark chocolate chunks.
Blue cookie butter ice cream mixed with crushed Oreos and chocolate chip cookie dough bites.
We make a pretty killer Cookies N Cream! Churned with Oreos for flavor, and tons of crushed Oreos mixed in!
This one is for the kiddos (well, adults too..), it's pink and blue cotton candy ice cream swirled together for a colorful and delicious treat. *gluten free*
Super dark chocolate ice cream with specks of 72% cacao dark chocolate. The cocoa is what makes is black!
Inspired by the snack that stole our childhood hearts! Vanilla frosting ice cream with cinnamon graham cookies and rainbow sprinkles.
Our Cookies N Cream ice cream but made with Gluten FreeOreos!
Imagine Cookies N Cream, but instead of regular Oreos, we use Golden Oreos (similar to Vienna Finger cookies)
This is a personal favorite, we steep real lavender flowers in the milk, and add lots of clover honey. It's also a pretty purple color. *gluten free*
BEENIE'S VAULT FLAVOR - available only in pints (online & in-store)! Straight-up glazed donut - infused ice cream, and it's amazing.
Captain Crunch cereal-infused milk is used to create this Beenie's original flavor. Tossed with chocolate-covered potato chips, this flavor should satisfy late-night cravings
Inspired by the hit video game, we make a special gray-colored caramel cookie ice cream (cobblestone) and mix it with cake crunchies (coal), red sprinkles (redstone), and green buttercream (grass). It tastes like ice cream cake!
Classic green mint ice cream with dark chocolate chunks. *gluten free*
White peppermint ice cream with crushed Mint Oreos!
Peach ice cream with red raspberry Swirl - limited time only! *gluten free
100% pure Sicilian Pistachio paste, chopped Pistachio nuts.
Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter swirl, crushed Reese's cupsand Reese's Pieces.
A classic Italian flavor of sweet cream and flaked dark chocolate, it's like Vanilla Chocolate Chip but better.
Strawberry ice cream with big slices of Strawberries.
BEENIE'S VAULT FLAVOR - available only in pints (online & in-store! If you've been to a Thai restaurant, you are aware of this delicious bright-orange exotic beverage made from black tea... try the ice cream version! *gluten free*
Toasted coconut ice cream with chocolate-covered toasted coconut flakes
Authentic Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla extract flavors this masterpiece of a Vanilla Bean ice cream. *gluten free
Vanilla ice cream with salty caramel swirl and brownie bites. A stand-by for many, can't go wrong with this one
Vegan-friendly, homemade with oat milk, coconut milk, and/or fresh fruit!
Oat milk birthday cake ice cream with rainbow sprinkles!
Vanilla oat milk with dairy-free mini chocolate chips and cookie dough bites.
Oat milk base, blended and chopped Oreos.
Oat milk base, with quality cocoa, and one of our favorites!
Coconut milk base, green mint and dairy-free dark chocolate flakes
Made with real mango fruit, this sorbet is amazing
Ice Cream Novelties made with our incredible ice cream - no cheap soft serve! Try one of our fun creations, perfect for all sorts of occasions!
Fresh baked salted Chocolate Chip cookies from The Artist Baker, cookie butter fudge ice cream, mini semi-sweet chocoalte chips.
A variety of 9 mini ice cream scoops sandwiched between Oreo cookies. Flavors: 2 x Cookies N Cream, 2 x Cookie Monster, 2 x Golden Oreo, 2 x Green Mint, 1 x Strawberry Lemon.
XL Toasted Coconut ice cream taco with a homemade waffle cone shell, gourmet salted caramel filling, chocolate coating, and toasted coconut.
XL Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla ice cream taco, with a homemade waffle cone shell, chocolate fudge filling, peanut coating and chopped peanuts.
XL Cinnamon Toast Crunch ice cream taco with a homemade waffle cone shell, gourmet salted caramel filling, caramel coating and Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal.
Two bone-shaped peanut butter ice cream treats for your dog! Profits are donated to 11th Hour Rescue. Ingredients: whole milk (lactose free), peanuts, cane sugar, gelatin, salt.
Bring the ice cream shop experience home with cones to go! Don't forget the ice cream!
Mini Leige Sugar Waffle, imported from Belgium. Heat in microwave for 20-30 seconds.
Made fresh in store.
Please request you choice of gluten free cone (sugar or wafer) in order notes.