Vegetables and Potatoes
Sliced Carrots
$8.95
Sweet Peas
$8.95
Boiled Potato
$8.95
Candied Sweets
$9.95
Home Fries
$9.95
String Beans
$8.95
Corn on the Cob
$8.95
Baked Yam
$8.95
Creamed Spinach
$10.95
Sarge's Homemade French Fries
$10.95
Fresh Broccoli
$8.95
Mashed Potato
$9.95
Baked Potato
$8.95
Beverages
100% Colombian Decaf
$4.50
Hot Chocolate
$4.50
Milk
$4.95
Iced Cream Soda
$9.95
Herbal Tea
$4.50
Premium Hot Tea
$4.50
Chocolate Milk
$5.95
100% Colombian Coffee
$4.50
Freshly Brewed Iced Tea
$5.00
Andy's 18th Hole 32 oz of 80% Freshly Brewed Iced Tea, 20% Lemonade, 100% Refreshing
$6.95
Fountain Soda
$4.25
Iced Coffee
$5.00
Milkshake's (Rich & Creamy)
$9.95
Snapple
$4.95
Gus Grown-Up Soda
$5.95
Bottled Water
$3.50
Canned Soda
$4.25
Dr. Brown's Canned Soda
$4.95
Legendary Egg Cream
$6.95
Mrs. Goldfarbs Unreal Deli Now at Sarge's
Mrs. Goldfarb's Unreal Ruben (Closed Sandwich)
$24.45
Mrs. Goldfarb's Unreal Plant Based Sandwich
$19.95
Mrs. Goldfarb's Unreal Turkey by the Pound
$6.25
Mrs. Goldfarb's Unreal Corned Beef by the Pound
$6.25
Salads, Fish and More by the 1/4 lb
1/4 lb Chopped Herring
$4.50
1 Herring Filet
$4.50
1/4 lb Large Lake Sturgeon
$17.25
1/4 lb Plain Cream Cheese
$3.50
1/4 lb Scallion Cream Cheese
$4.25
1/4 lb Belly Lox (Salty)
$13.75
1/4 lb Vegetable Cream Cheese
$4.25
1/4 lb Smoked Whitefish
$8.00
1/4 lb Baked Kippered Salmon
$13.75
1/4 lb Baked Salmon Salad
$8.25
1/4 lb Smoked Sable
$17.25
1/4 lb Cucumber Salad
$3.50
1/4 lb Herring in Cream Sauce
$5.00
1/4 lb Shrimp Salad
$6.70
1/4 lb Nova Scotia Salmon
$13.75
1/4 lb Whitefish Salad
$8.25
1/4 lb Macaroni Salad
$3.50
1/4 lb Potato Salad
$3.50
1/4 lb Coleslaw
$3.50
1/4 lb Chicken Salad
$5.75
1/4 lb Egg Salad
$4.75
1/4 lb Chopped Chicken Liver
$5.50
1/4 lb Tuna Salad
$5.75
Side Orders
Creamy Coleslaw
$7.95
Old Fashioned Onion Rings
$14.45
Sarge's Homemade French Fries
$10.95
Macaroni Salad
$7.95
Potato Salad
$7.95
Sarge's Famous Cheese Fries
$12.95
Cucumber Salad
$7.95
Applesauce
$6.95
Kasha Varnishkes
$12.95
Stuffing
$9.95
Sweet Potato Fries
$11.95
Egg Barley and Mushrooms
$12.95
Tossed Green Salad
$10.95
Pickled Tomatoes
$7.95
Loaded Baked Potato
$13.95
Cranberry Sauce
$6.95
Wedge of Lettuce
$8.95
Turkey Bacon
$9.95
Sliced Bacon
$9.95
Sarge's Famous Loaded Fries
$14.95
Breakfast Sausage
$9.95
Slow Cooked Baked Beans
$10.95
Green Olives
$7.95
Cottage Cheese
$7.95
Hot Sauerkraut
$7.95
Hot Peppers
$8.95
Fried Mushrooms and Onions
$9.95
Sweet Peppers
$8.95
Cold Sauerkraut
$7.95
Corned Beef Hash
$19.45
Black Olives
$7.95
Canadian Bacon
$9.95
Special Hot Open Sandwiches
Sarge's Favorite Sandwich
$31.45
Hot Open Slow Cooked Brisket Sandwich
$31.45
Hot Open Fresh Roasted Turkey Sandwich
$31.45
The Third Avenue Sandwich
$36.45
Hot Open Slow Cooked Roast Beef Sandwich
$31.45
Turkey Favorite Sandwich on Potato Pancake
$31.45
Chopped Steak Sandwich
$32.45
Roumanian Steak Sandwich
$33.45
Combination Sandwiches
3. Corned Beef and Pastrami Sandwich
$31.95
7. Fresh Roasted Turkey and Corned Beef Sandwich
$31.95
5. Fresh Roasted Turkey and Slow Cooked Roast Beef Sandwich
$31.95
14. Slow Cooked Hot Brisket of Beef Sandwich
$31.95
10. Fresh Roasted Turkey, Ham and Swiss Sandwich
$31.95
19. Custom Combo Sandwich
$31.95
15. Ruben (Open Faced)
$32.45
16. Tuna Melt
$27.45
18. Fresh Roasted Turkey Reuben
$32.45
17. Robin (Open Faced)
$32.45
20. The Hudson (Born 12-12-2018)
$34.45
6. Fresh Roasted Turkey and Tongue Sandwich
$31.95
4. Corned Beef and Tongue Sandwich
$31.95
2. Pastrami, Tongue and Swiss Sandwich
$31.95
12. Fresh Roasted Turkey and Chopped Liver Sandwich
$31.95
9. Fresh Roasted Turkey, Pastrami and Tongue Sandwich
$31.95
8. Fresh Roasted Turkey, Corned Beef and Tongue Sandwich
$31.95
11. Fresh Roasted Turkey, Tongue and Swiss Sandwich
$31.95
1. Corned Beef, Tongue and Swiss Sandwich
$31.95
13. Corned Beef and Chopped Liver Sandwich
$31.95
Sarge's Homemade Cheesecakes
Oreo Cheesecake
$12.95
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cheesecake
$12.95
Original New York Cheesecake
$11.95
Cheesecake Topped with Fresh Strawberries
$12.95
Smoked Fish Platters
Maatjes Herring
$15.95
Smoked Sable with Cream Cheese on a Bagel
$34.95
Lake Sturgeon on a Bagel with Cream Chese
$34.95
Pickled Herring Fillet
$15.95
Chopped Herring
$15.95
Baked Kippered Salmon on a Bagel
$23.95
Smoked Fish Supreme
$51.95
Herring Sampler
$23.95
Smoked Whitefish with a Bagel and Cream Cheese
$23.95
Pickled Herring
$15.95
Pick Two Combo
$42.95
Nova Scotia Salmon or Belly Lox and Cream Cheese on Bagel
$23.95
Nova Special
$36.95
Entrees a la Sarge
Specials
$29.45
Calves Liver Steak
$34.45
Corned Beef with Cabbage
$34.45
Boiled Chicken in a Pot with Matzo Ball
$33.95
Grilled Double Chicken Breast
$32.45
Stuffed Cabbage
$34.45
Old-Fashioned Meatloaf
$31.45
1/2 Slow Cooked Roast Chicken
$33.45
Pot Roast
$34.45
Hungarian Beef Goulash
$33.45
Fresh Sliced Roast Turkey
$33.45
Chicken Pot Pie
Homemade Chicken Pot Pie
$21.45
Sarge's Covid Creations
Jumbo Veggie Burger
$18.45
Whole Chocolate Babka
$16.95
The Dirty Deeds
$25.95
The Mulberry Street
$21.95
Tater Tots
$10.95
The Suzy Greenberg
$25.95
Sweet Baby Dave’s Smokehouse Pastrami
$28.95
The Chicken Loco
$27.95
It's Key-Lime Pie Time
Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies (Individual Serve)
$8.95
Dairy Specialties
Matzo Brie
$20.45
Macaroni and Cheese
$11.95
Homemade Cheese Blintzes
$25.45
Homemade Potato Pirogen (Boiled or Fried)
$24.45
Potato Pancakes
$20.45
Homemade Noodle Kugel
$12.95
Andy's Favorites
Sarge's French Dip Sandwich
$28.95
Sarge's Cheese Steak
$30.95
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
$24.95
BBQ Slow Cooked Brisket Sandwich
$29.95
Boneless Chicken Sandwich
$20.95
Twin Double Sandwich
$29.95
The Monster Sandwich (Feeds 2 to 4 or One Hungry Person)
$62.95
Fried Filet of Sole Sandwich
$24.95
Sarge's Homemade Soups
1 Quart Noodle Soup
$20.90
1 Pint Noodle Soup
$10.95
1 Quart Mushroom Barley Soup
$20.90
Kreplach Soup for 2
$29.95
Borscht with Sour Cream Soup (1 Pint)
$10.95
Borscht with Sour Cream and a Boiled Potato
$12.95
1 Quart Vegetable Soup
$20.90
1 Quart Split-Pea Soup w/ croutons
$20.90
French Onion Soup Au Gratin
$12.95
Matzo Ball Soup for 2
$29.95
1 Pint Chicken Consomme
$8.95
1 Quart Chicken Consomme Soup
$16.90
1 Quart Matzo Ball Soup
$20.90
1 Pint Mushroom Barley Soup
$10.95
1 Pint Vegetable Soup
$10.95
Souper Soup
$16.95
1 Pint Split-Pea Soup w/croutons
$10.95
1 Pint Matzo Ball Soup
$10.95
Eggs and Omelettes
Eggs with Side of Tongue
$29.45
Tongue Omelette
$28.45
Bologna and Eggs Omelette
$23.45
Eggs with Side of Salami
$24.45
Canadian Bacon and Eggs
$22.45
Frankfurter Omelette
$20.45
Eggs with Side of Sturgeon
$28.45
Tomato Omelette
$19.45
Eggs with Side of Corned Beef
$25.45
Corned Beef Omelette
$24.45
Eggs with a Side of Franks
$21.45
Turkey Omelette
$24.45
Sturgeon Omelette
$27.45
Eggs with Side of Pastrami
$26.45
Ham and Eggs
$21.45
Eggs Benedict
$24.45
Swiss Cheese Omelette
$21.45
Sausage and Eggs
$21.45
Eggs with Side of Nova
$26.45
Mushroom Omelette
$20.45
Nova and Onions Scrambled
$25.45
Bacon and Eggs
$21.45
Spinach and Feta Omelette
$22.45
Salami and Eggs Omelette
$23.45
Onion Omelette
$18.45
Delicatessen Omelette
$30.45
Mushroom and Onion Omelette
$22.45
Pastrami Omelette
$25.45
Western Omelette
$21.45
Garden Omelette
$23.45
Steak and Eggs
$31.45
American Cheese Omelette
$20.45
3 Fresh Eggs Any Style
$17.45
Corned Beef Hash
$27.45
Sarge's Sandwich Board
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
$27.95
Hot Corned Beef Sandwich
$26.95
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato Sandwich
$14.95
2 Eggs, Bacon and American Cheese on a Roll
$11.95
Grilled American Cheese and Bacon Sandwich
$14.95
Half Soup and Sandwich
$24.95
Fresh Roasted Turkey Sandwich
$22.95
Grilled American Cheese Sandwich
$12.95
Tuna Salad Sandwich
$19.95
Hot Brisket of Beef Sandwich
$26.95
Slow Cooked Roast Beef Sandwich
$25.95
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$19.95
Turkey Pastrami Sandwich
$23.95
Egg Salad Sandwich
$17.95
2 Eggs and Bacon on a Roll
$10.95
Grilled Imported Swiss Cheese Sandwich
$13.95
2 Eggs and American Cheese on a Roll
$10.95
American Cheese Sandwich
$13.95
2 Eggs on a Roll
$8.95
Hard Salami Sandwich
$22.95
Chopped Liver Sandwich
$21.95
Smoked Whitefish Salad Sandwich
$20.95
Salami Sandwich
$21.95
Tongue Sandwich
$28.95
Grilled Imported Swiss Cheese and Bacon Sandwich
$15.95
Meatloaf Sandwich
$21.95
2 Eggs, Ham and American Cheese on a Roll
$11.95
Bologna Sandwich
$21.95
Boiled Ham Sandwich
$20.95
Liverwurst Sandwich
$18.95
Imported Swiss Cheese Sandwich
$16.95
Shrimp Salad Sandwich
$21.95
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
$20.95
Grilled Salami Sandwich
$21.95
Rolled Beef
$27.95
2 Eggs and Ham on a Roll
$10.95
Salami and Egg Sandwich
$18.95
2 Eggs and Sausage on a Roll
$10.95
2 Eggs, Sausage and American Cheese on a Roll
$11.95
Sarge's Famous 10 oz Prime Beef Burgers
Bleu Cheeseburger
$23.45
Battery Park Burger
$26.45
Central Park Burger
$27.45
The Cookout Burger
$26.45
Bacon Burger
$22.45
Pizza Burger
$23.45
Pastrami Burger
$27.45
Bronx Sliders
$21.45
Beef Burger
$21.45
Patty Melt Burger
$23.45
Turkey Burger
$19.45
Bacon Cheeseburger
$23.45
Turkey Cheeseburger
$20.45
Cheeseburger
$22.45
Skyscraper Burger
$28.45
Hot & Cold Cut Platters
Sliced Cold Tongue Platter
$36.95
Cold Slow Cooked Roast Beef Platter
$31.95
Hot Corned Beef Platter
$33.45
Cold Sliced Roast Turkey Platter
$30.95
Combination Corned Beef and Pastrami Platter
$35.45
Hot Brisket Platter
$33.45
Hot Pastrami Platter
$35.45
Assorted Cold Cuts a la Sarge Platter
$41.45
Triple Decker Sandwiches
K. Club Sandwich
$28.95
L. Junior Club Sandwich
$27.95
B. Fresh Roasted Turkey, Pastrami and Swiss Cheese Sandwich
$33.95
E. Tongue, Hot Pastrami and Salami Sandwich
$33.95
G. Fresh Roasted Turkey, Roast Beef and Chopped Liver Sandwich
$33.95
I. Fresh Sliced Roasted Turkey, Sliced Egg and Bacon Sandwich
$28.95
D. Tongue, Chopped Liver and Salami Sandwich
$33.95
A. Fresh Roasted Turkey, Tongue and Corned Beef Sandwich
$33.95
H. Corned Beef, Tongue and Chopped Liver Sandwich
$33.95
C. Roast Beef and Tongue Sandwich
$33.95
F. Chopped Liver, Sliced Egg and Bacon Sandwich
$33.95
J. Hand Sliced Nova Scotia Salmon, Sturgeon and Cream Cheese Sandwich
$40.95
By the Pound
Pickles 1 Quart
$11.95
Slice of Rye Bread
$1.40
Matzoh Ball (1 Piece)
$4.50
1 lb Coleslaw
$11.00
Half Loaf of Rye Bread
$7.95
Kreplach (Boiled) (1 Piece)
$5.00
1 lb Tuna Salad
$20.00
1 lb Fresh Roasted Turkey
$31.00
1 lb Pastrami
$42.00
1 lb Potato Salad
$11.00
1 lb Macaroni Salad
$11.00
1 lb Hand Sliced Nova Scotia Salmon
$52.00
1 lb Chicken Salad
$20.00
Whole Loaf of Rye Bread
$14.90
1 lb Corned Beef
$39.00
1 lb Chopped Chicken Liver
$19.00
1 lb Cucumber Salad
$11.00
1 lb Scallion Cream Cheese
$14.00
1 lb Herring in Onions and Cream Sauce
$17.00
1 lb Raw Beef Franks (Aprox 6-7)
$23.00
1 lb Egg Salad
$16.00
1 lb Liverwurst
$15.00
1 lb Brisket of Beef
$37.00
1 lb Swiss Cheese
$16.00
1 lb Boiled Ham
$16.00
1 lb Belly Lox
$52.00
1 lb Smoked Whitefish
$29.00
1 lb American Cheese
$12.00
1 lb Hard Salami
$29.00
1 lb Sauerkraut (COLD)
$8.00
1 lb Plain Cream Cheese
$11.00
1 lb Smoked Sable
$66.00
1 lb Turkey Pastrami
$33.00
1 lb Roast Beef
$35.00
1 lb Whitefish Salad
$30.00
1 lb Sauerkraut (HOT)
$8.00
1 lb Chopped Herring
$15.00
1 lb Raw Knockwurst (Approx 4)
$23.00
1 lb Rolled Beef
$42.00
1 lb Baked Salmon Salad
$30.00
1 lb Shrimp Salad
$26.00
1 lb Beef Salami
$22.00
1 lb Vegetable Cream Cheese
$14.00
1 lb Beef Bologna
$22.00
1 lb Cheddar Cheese
$14.00
1 lb Muenster Cheese
$14.00
1 lb Mozzarella Cheese
$14.00
1 lb Provolone Cheese
$14.00
1 lb Baked Kippered Salmon
$52.00
1 lb Large Lake Sturgeon
$66.00
1 lb Tongue
$45.00
Whole Challah Bread
$9.95
Pint of Gravy
$6.95
From the Griddle
Stack of Pancakes
$18.45
French Toast
$18.45
Flavored Pancakes
$21.45
Block Buster Knishes
Block Buster Stuffed Square Potato Knishes
$14.95
Fruits and Juices
Tomato Juice
$5.95
Grapefruit Juice
$5.95
Cranberry Juice
$5.95
Fresh Fruit Cup
$8.95
Apple Juice
$5.95
Orange Juice
$6.95
Fish
Fried Jumbo Fantail Shrimp
$34.45
Fresh Fillet of Sole
$34.45
Beer Battered Fish and Chips
$31.45
Fresh Salmon Fillet
$34.45
Salad Platters
Chicken Salad Platter
$22.95
Shrimp Salad Platter
$27.95
Tuna Salad Platter
$22.95
Combination Salad Platter
$24.95
Egg Salad Platter
$21.95
Smoked Whitefish Salad Platter
$27.95
California Salad Platter
$19.95
Baked Smoked Salmon Salad Platter
$27.95
Gefilte Fish Salad Platter
$22.95
Whole Shrimp Platter
$28.95
Chopped Chicken Liver Salad Platter
$22.95
Cold Cuts and Cheese by the 1/4 lb
1/4 lb Mozzarella Cheese
$4.25
1/4 lb Cheddar Cheese
$4.25
1/4 lb Provolone Cheese
$4.25
1/4 lb Beef Bologna
$6.25
1/4 lb Raw Beef Franks
$4.25
1/4 lb Turkey Pastrami
$9.00
1/4 lb Tongue
$12.00
1/4 lb First Cut Extra Lean Brisket of Beef
$10.50
1/4 lb Liverwurst
$4.50
1/4 lb Rolled Beef
$11.50
1/4 lb American Cheese
$3.75
1/4 lb Brisket of Beef
$10.00
1/4 lb Boiled Ham
$4.75
1/4 lb Swiss Cheese
$4.25
1/4 lb First Cut Extra Lean Corned Beef
$10.50
1/4 lb Beef Salami
$6.25
1/4 lb First Cut Extra Lean Pastrami
$12.00
1/4 lb Hard Salami
$8.00
1/4 lb Slow Cooked Roast Beef
$9.50
1/4 lb Muenster Cheese
$4.25
1/4 lb Corned Beef
$10.50
1/4 lb Pastrami
$11.50
1/4 lb Sliced Fresh Roasted Turkey
$8.50
Muffins and Toast
Roll with Cream Cheese
$6.95
English Muffin with Cream Cheese
$6.95
English Muffin with Butter
$5.95
Buttered Toast
$4.95
Bagel with Butter
$5.95
Muffin
$6.95
Roll with Butter
$5.95
Bagel with Cream Cheese
$6.95
Bagel
$2.50
Snap-O-Razzo Hot Dog (Born May 2023)
Snap-O-Razzo Hot Dog
$8.95
Sarge's Famous Desserts
Large Black and White Cookie
$5.95
Large Chocolate Chip Cookie
$5.95
Ruggelach (6 Pieces)
$9.95
Banana Cream Pie
$10.95
Pecan Pie
$10.95
Apple Strudel
$10.95
Rice Pudding
$6.95
Chocolate Cream Pie
$10.95
Carrot Cake
$11.95
German Chocolate Cake
$11.95
Chocolate Mousse Cake
$11.95
Red Velvet Cake
$11.95
Linzer Tart
$5.95
All Butter Pound Cake
$6.95
Whole Chocolate Babka
$16.95
7 Layer Cake
$11.95
Lemon Meringue Pie
$10.95
Deep-Dish Fruit Pie
$10.95
French Ice Cream
$8.95
Chocolate Eclair
$8.95
Marble Halvah
$10.95
Fruit Jello
$7.95
Chocolate Pudding
$6.95
Steaks and Chops
Sliced London Broil
$43.45
Romanian Tenderloin Steak
$43.45
Appetizers
Stuffed Cabbage
$18.45
Buffalo Wings
$23.45
Chopped Liver
$15.95
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
$16.45
Chicken Tenders
$17.45
Colossal Gulf Shrimp Cocktail
$22.95
The Sampler
$24.45
Gefilte Fish
$11.95
Stuffed Derma (Kishka) with Gravy
$18.45
Fried Kreplach
$16.45
Swedish Meatballs
$17.95
Uptown Salads
Spinach Salad
$21.95
Buffalo Chicken Salad
$22.95
Greek Salad
$22.95
Chef's Salad
$25.95
Cobb Salad
$25.95
Caesar Salad
$19.95
Chopped Salad
$21.95
Hot Dog Corner
Frank on a Bun
$7.95
Sarge's Noshes
Grilled Knockwurst on a Bun
$10.95
Deli Wellington
$16.95
Block Buster Stuffed Square Potato Knishes
$14.95
Potato Knish (Round or Square)
$8.95
Kasha Knish
$8.95
Spinach Knish
$8.95
Potato Pancake with Sour Cream
$7.95
Potato Pancake with Apple Sauce
$7.95